[Iccrg] ctcp review: big picture issues (3 of 4)

[Michael Welzl]

> I am not sure what the RG's job is in general.  With regards to
> reviewing this for TCPM the job of the RG is, as far as I understand it,
> to evaluate the safety statement in the document.  In this document that
> statement does not say it is safe enough to play with, it says it "is
> safe to deploy on the current Internet".

The way I see it, this is the RG's main concern, and...


> I would like to think that the RG provides more than simply this review
> for TCPM and that in fact other technical comments about proposed CC
> schemes would be in bounds.

...surely such comments are in bounds.

cheers,
Michael